CitizenRE strikes me as a religious cult working the public's fears, good-hearted convictions, and lack of knowledge to forward their own agenda. They espouse belief over fact, loyalty to company above all else, and smear the detractors with the 'We'll show you' line. Two years from now we will all laugh at the ridiculous hype that surrounded this company that is more marketing than manufacturing. They use borrowed money to tell everyone how wonderful they are, spend no money on an actual staff, and sell no products or services.
So far as I can tell, there is no major industry in today's marketplace that works on the business model put forward by these folks. I wonder if 100 years ago Henry Ford had a similar business model we would be driving cars today. Imagine, instead of creating a manufacturing technique to make his product affordable, Henry Ford said he would drive down costs by 'eliminating the middle-men' and went about trying to build the parts supplier, the car manufacturer, the dealerships, and the service stations across the country. His company would then give people the cars for free, pay it's employees who don't really work for the company only when another person takes that free car, and only charges them for the gas, which must be purchased from him. Granted the analogy isn't as clean as I make it sound, but no other industry works like this for a reason. Parts suppliers, manufacturers, retailers, installers, service technicians all have a role to play in every industry, and no amount of marketing is going to convince the majority of consumers that one company can do it all well.
I am not trying to portray CitizenRE as a company full of crooks. In fact, my guess is these people are hard-working, honest folks who are trying to make a difference in this crazy world we live in. They are, however, deluting themselves. In the short term, they are going to give this industry a bad name, but eventually they will fall apart or turn into some business model that works. I guess I do agree with CitizenRE on one thing, we'll just have to wait & see.
This piece by NPR I think helps illustrate my points exactly.
CitizenRE NPR story
Friday, March 23, 2007
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)